sell.py: optimal-ask model via empirical first-passage, not random walk

A driftless-random-walk closed form was tried first and backtested wrong
against 3 years of real exchange history (overstated touch probability
2-4x, confounded by discrete daily-VWAP sampling and real mean-reversion).
Replaced with puga.history.empirical_touch(): a non-parametric estimator
measuring first-passage directly from a ticker's own history, conditioned
on current state (trailing-60d z-score) since mean reversion's effect
depends on where price is now, not just move size. Queue-depth (existing
resting quantity) folds in as a deterministic shift of the hitting time,
not a max, ranking by the resulting hit_factor rather than a point
estimate of median days (which created a false cliff at the 50%-touched
threshold). Optional fixed-horizon right-censoring avoids recency bias
in "never reached" samples.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
2026-10-10 23:06:34 +02:00
co-authored by Claude Sonnet 5
parent b9b3b9bf4e
commit c4bcc8f42c
3 changed files with 300 additions and 12 deletions
+126 -3
View File
@@ -1,6 +1,6 @@
"""Daily exchange price/volume series from FIO's cxpc candles, shared by tools/history.py and
tools/undervalued.py."""
import datetime
"""Daily exchange price/volume series from FIO's cxpc candles, shared by tools/history.py,
tools/undervalued.py, tools/sell.py and puga/parkcash.py."""
import datetime, math, statistics
from . import fio
@@ -11,3 +11,126 @@ def daily_prices(tk: str, cx: str) -> dict:
if e.get("Interval") == "DAY_ONE" and e.get("Traded"):
out[datetime.datetime.fromtimestamp(e["DateEpochMs"] / 1000, datetime.timezone.utc).date()] = (e["Volume"] / e["Traded"], e["Traded"])
return out
def trading_days(tk: str, cx: str, days: int = 30) -> list[tuple[datetime.date, float]]:
"""(date, units traded) for actual trading days in the last `days` CALENDAR days - fio.cxpc
only emits a row when a trade happened, so a sparse ticker needs a real calendar cutoff here,
not "last N rows" (that would silently reach back far more than `days` actual days)."""
cutoff = datetime.datetime.now(datetime.timezone.utc).date() - datetime.timedelta(days=days)
return sorted((d, v) for d, (_, v) in daily_prices(tk, cx).items() if d >= cutoff)
def trade_gaps_days(dates: list[datetime.date]) -> list[int]:
return [(b - a).days for a, b in zip(dates, dates[1:])]
def full_series(tk: str, cx: str) -> list[tuple[datetime.date, float]]:
"""Full traded-price history (all available days, not windowed) ascending by date - for the
empirical first-passage estimator below, which needs as much real history as exists rather
than a 30d window, especially for distant target prices."""
return sorted((d, p) for d, (p, _) in daily_prices(tk, cx).items())
def _trailing_zscores(logp: list[float], trail: int = 60, min_window: int = 10) -> list[float | None]:
"""z-score of each day's log-price against its own trailing `trail`-day mean/stdev (None where
there isn't `min_window` days of history yet). A flat window (stdev 0) scores 0, not None -
the price IS exactly at its own flat mean, that's a real, defined state, not missing data."""
z = [None] * len(logp)
for i in range(len(logp)):
window = logp[max(0, i - trail + 1):i + 1]
if len(window) < min_window:
continue
m = statistics.mean(window)
sd = statistics.stdev(window) if len(window) > 1 else 0.0
z[i] = (logp[i] - m) / sd if sd > 1e-12 else 0.0
return z
def empirical_touch(series: list[tuple[datetime.date, float]], y: float, rate: float,
condition_on_state: bool = True, trail: int = 60, z_tol: float = 0.5,
horizon: int | None = None) -> dict:
"""Non-parametric first-passage stats for a target log-move `y` = ln(target_price/start_price),
estimated directly from how often and how fast this ticker's REAL price history has made moves
of that size - no random-walk/GBM assumption, so real mean-reversion shows up directly in the
result instead of being assumed away (see docs/decisions.md for the evidence that real prices
here do mean-revert).
Mean reversion means the answer depends on WHERE price is now relative to its own recent
trend, not just on the move size - a 20% rise is more/less likely depending on whether today
is already above or below the recent mean. With `condition_on_state` (default), only historical
start days whose z-score against a trailing `trail`-day mean are within `z_tol` of TODAY's
z-score (the series' last point) are used - keeping the estimate non-parametric (no fitted
mean-reversion speed/strength) while still making it state-aware. Falls back to using every
start day if there isn't enough history to compute today's z-score, or if the z_tol band is
empty (too little data to condition on, not a real "always/never" signal).
For each eligible historical day i, scan forward for the first day j>i where the cumulative
log-return reaches y (>= y if y>0, <= y if y<0). Contributes e^(-rho*dt) to the discount-factor
average, where dt is the elapsed calendar days and rho = ln(1+rate); a day that NEVER reaches y
within the observed history contributes 0 (not excluded - excluding right-censored samples
would bias the estimate toward only the easy cases, since the hard/slow/never cases are exactly
the ones that get cut off by the data running out).
CAVEAT: `series` is daily VWAP (one point per day), a discrete sample of a continuous price
path. Discrete monitoring can only miss touches, never invent them - an intraday spike that
crosses the target and reverts before the next day's VWAP is computed shows up as "not
touched" here even though a resting ask would genuinely have filled on it. So this estimator
is systematically conservative: real touch probability/hit_factor is at least this high, likely
somewhat higher, and the resulting "sell now" lean (tools/sell.py --tiers) is a bit stronger
than fully warranted. Standard discrete-monitoring barrier corrections (e.g. Broadie-Glasserman-
Kou) put the gap at roughly 0.58*sigma*sqrt(step) per sampling interval for a short horizon -
real at short horizons, shrinking as the horizon grows. Not corrected for here.
Without `horizon`, "never reached" means "not reached before the series ends" - which gives
start days near the end of history much less time to ever register a hit than start days near
the beginning, purely from running out of data, not economics. With `horizon` (days), only
start days with at least that much real history remaining are used, and the search for day j
is capped at `horizon` days past i for all of them - every sample gets the same fixed window,
so touched_frac/hit_factor are comparable across samples instead of recency-biased. Off by
default (every caller currently omits it) since it discards the most recent `horizon` days of
start-day samples entirely - a real tradeoff, not a strict improvement on small histories.
Returns: hit_factor (empirical E[e^-rho*tau], the discounted-value multiplier), touched_frac
(share of start days that ever reached y at all within their remaining history), median_days
(None if touched_frac < 0.5 - can't report a median that was never reached more than half the
time), n (sample count - note: these are heavily OVERLAPPING windows, not independent draws,
so n overstates the effective sample size; same caveat as the backtest this reuses).
"""
n = len(series)
if y == 0 or n < 2:
return {"hit_factor": 1.0, "touched_frac": 1.0, "median_days": 0.0, "n": n}
dates = [d for d, _ in series]
logp = [math.log(p) for _, p in series if p > 0]
rho = math.log(1 + rate)
eligible = range(n - 1)
if horizon is not None:
eligible = [i for i in eligible if (dates[-1] - dates[i]).days >= horizon]
if condition_on_state:
z = _trailing_zscores(logp, trail)
z_today = z[-1]
if z_today is not None:
matched = [i for i in eligible if z[i] is not None and abs(z[i] - z_today) <= z_tol]
if matched:
eligible = matched
discount_sum, hit_days, count = 0.0, [], 0
for i in eligible:
target = logp[i] + y
found = None
for j in range(i + 1, n):
if horizon is not None and (dates[j] - dates[i]).days > horizon:
break
if (y > 0 and logp[j] >= target) or (y < 0 and logp[j] <= target):
found = j
break
count += 1
if found is not None:
dt = (dates[found] - dates[i]).days
discount_sum += math.exp(-rho * dt)
hit_days.append(dt)
touched_frac = len(hit_days) / count if count else 0.0
median_days = statistics.median(hit_days) if touched_frac >= 0.5 else None
return {"hit_factor": discount_sum / count if count else 0.0, "touched_frac": touched_frac,
"median_days": median_days, "n": count}